Author: Vanessa Edmonds, Executive Director, U2030
Machine Learning (ML) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) are rapidly transforming our world, influencing everything from healthcare and education to transportation—and utilities. As the energy and water sectors increasingly rely on AI and ML to optimize operations, improve customer service, and drive sustainability, it's crucial to understand how these technologies work—and how diverse data and perspectives are critical their effectiveness.
Understanding AI & Machine Learning
Although people often use "AI" and "ML" interchangeably, they are distinct concepts. AI is the broader field focused on creating systems that perform tasks requiring human intelligence, such as problem-solving, reasoning, and decision-making. AI can forecast energy demand, optimize water usage, or detect utility infrastructure faults.
Machine Learning (ML) is a subset of AI that develops algorithms that allow systems to learn from data and improve their performance over time. ML systems are particularly useful in applications such as predictive maintenance for utility equipment and energy consumption forecasting, where algorithms refine predictions based on new data.
How AI "Learns": A Brain-Inspired Process
In AI systems, particularly those using Machine Learning, the learning process mimics the human brain’s pattern recognition. Just as our brain processes information in layers, ML models are structured in layers to detect increasingly complex patterns. For example, an AI system might learn to recognize usage patterns based on weather data, seasonal fluctuations, and past energy consumption in energy management.
However, this learning depends heavily on the data. To adapt to real-world complexities—whether managing energy grids or optimizing water systems—AI systems require comprehensive and diverse training data. Just as children learn from varied experiences, AI needs diverse inputs to entirely understand the world around them.
The Role of Data in AI & Machine Learning
The effectiveness of AI and ML systems depends on the quality and variety of the data used to train them. For instance, energy consumption patterns can differ widely between urban and rural areas in the utility sector. Training an AI model on data from one community type may lead to inaccurate predictions or resource misallocation.
Developers must expose AI systems to diverse datasets to perform effectively. For energy, this means incorporating data on various energy sources, weather patterns, and regional energy needs. Similarly, water management systems must be trained on data reflecting different environmental conditions and user behaviors. Without this diversity, the system's predictions can narrow, leading to inefficiencies or failures.
The Critical Importance of Diversity in AI
Machine Learning models, like those used in energy management or water systems, are only as effective as the data inputs. Training an AI system on limited or homogeneous data fails to recognize the full complexity of the world it aims to manage. For example, a water management AI trained solely on data from areas with abundant rainfall may need help managing resources in drier regions. Similarly, energy forecasting AI that only uses data from affluent urban areas may miss fluctuations in energy demand driven by socioeconomic factors.
A famous experiment involving kittens illustrates this principle. Researchers exposed kittens to only vertical or horizontal lines during their critical learning period, causing them to recognize only the type of line they saw. Similarly, AI systems trained on narrow datasets will only detect patterns within those confines, missing broader complexities.
Another example is an AI system trained to judge beauty contests. This system was primarily trained on images of white contestants, failing to recognize beauty standards from other cultures. This exposed potential inclusivity concerns when systems are not exposed to the diversity of the people they serve.
The Dangers of Narrow Data in Utilities
The risks of narrow data in utility AI systems are evident. For example, predictive maintenance models could miss fault patterns if trained on data from one region or set of machines. Similarly, AI systems predicting energy consumption could only interpret usage patterns during unusual weather events or high-demand periods if trained on diverse conditions.
One high-profile case involves the risks of using AI in recruitment, where an algorithm trained on biased historical data favored male candidates, perpetuating gender discrimination. Similarly, in the energy sector, AI trained mainly on data from centralized grids could need help managing distributed energy resources like solar panels or wind turbines, leading to inefficiencies.
A Case Study: AI and Water Management
A clear example of the need for diverse data in AI exists in water management. Predicting water demand, managing irrigation, and monitoring water quality require data reflecting diverse geographic, economic, and social conditions. AI trained only on data from urban systems may fail to address the needs of rural or underserved communities, leading to inefficient water usage or system failures.
The Need for Diverse Voices in AI Development
For AI and Machine Learning to serve everyone fairly, the teams developing these systems must reflect the diversity of the communities they serve. This involves energy, water management, environmental science, and public policy experts for utilities, ensuring that AI developers consider the full spectrum of user experiences and community needs.
Diverse perspectives are essential for fairness and effectiveness. When utility systems don't have input from all relevant stakeholders, critical knowledge gaps can lead to systems that function differently than intended.
Caroline Chavier's TED Talk: Diversity in AI Development
Caroline Chavier, in her TED Talk, "Diversity & Women in AI", argues that the lack of diverse voices in AI development is a human rights issue. Without input from diverse perspectives, AI systems will reinforce the biases of those who created them. In utility systems, this can result in solutions that work well for some communities but fail to address the needs of others, especially marginalized or underserved populations.
5 Steps Towards a More Equitable Future
The future of AI and ML in utilities is promising, but only if diversity and inclusivity are priorities in design and development. Just as kittens need exposure to various lines to see the world clearly, AI systems need diverse data to understand the world accurately. For AI to effectively manage energy grids, optimize water distribution, and improve sustainability, developers must train it on data that reflects a full range of environmental, social, and economic factors.
This requires utility leaders to take proactive and strategic actions to ensure AI and ML technologies serve all stakeholders equitably. Here are five key steps that can help embed diversity and inclusivity into the very foundation of AI development and deployment:
1. Establish a Diverse, Multidisciplinary AI Development Team
Senior leaders should ensure that AI and ML development teams are composed of individuals from diverse genders and backgrounds, including those with expertise in energy, water management, environmental science, public policy, and social justice. Involving a range of perspectives—such as those from different geographic regions, socioeconomic backgrounds, and demographic groups—will help ensure that the developed AI systems reflect the diverse needs of all communities served by the utility.
2. Promote Inclusive Data Collection Practices
AI and ML systems are only as effective as their data inputs. Leaders must ensure that developers train AI models on comprehensive and representative datasets that reflect the full spectrum of environmental, social, and economic factors. For example, data should encompass urban and rural energy consumption patterns, regional water usage differences, and socioeconomic disparities that may impact energy and water needs. This also includes actively seeking data from marginalized communities often underrepresented in utility models.
3. Incorporate Equity Audits and Bias Testing
Utility leaders should mandate regular equity audits and bias testing of all AI systems to prevent unintentional biases in AI algorithms. This involves assessing whether the AI models produce fair, unbiased outcomes across all demographics, particularly marginalized or underserved groups. Utilities must correct any discovered biases by refining the datasets, adjusting algorithms, and re-evaluating the development process to ensure equitable results.
4. Foster Partnerships with External Experts and Stakeholders
Utility companies should actively collaborate with external organizations—such as community advocacy groups, academic institutions, and diversity-focused tech organizations—to gain broader insights into the needs of diverse populations. These partnerships can help identify gaps in current AI models and data, ensuring that the technology is inclusive and serves all stakeholders effectively. Public consultations and workshops with community leaders can also help integrate community input and concerns into AI development.
5. Invest in Ongoing Education and Training on Diversity in AI
Senior leaders should commit to ongoing education and training programs for their AI teams on the importance of diversity and inclusivity in AI development. This includes providing training on recognizing and mitigating bias, promoting cultural competency, and understanding the social implications of AI systems. Leaders can also encourage professional development by sponsoring participation in industry events, workshops, or certifications focused on inclusive AI design and implementation.
Conclusion
The promise of AI and ML in the utility sector is immense. Still, for these technologies to reach their full potential, utilities must prioritize diversity and inclusivity. By taking intentional steps to ensure that AI systems include comprehensive, representative data and inclusive development practices, utility leaders can create more intelligent, more equitable systems that benefit all utility customers and employees—regardless of location, income, or background.
Prioritizing diverse voices, datasets, and perspectives not only fosters fairness but also enhances the effectiveness of AI, driving greater operational efficiency, sustainability, and resilience.
Comments